Join Our Mailing List

Follow Us


Current Articles | RSS Feed RSS Feed

Education Quality in Latin America Comes Down to Teachers

describe the image

It seems like almost every day more evidence comes in showing that teachers are the most important single factor when it comes to education quality. While that makes intuitive sense, it is also critical to have empirical evidence to support it.

A better understanding of the central role that teachers play will help us focus reform efforts and target resources more effectively. It also confronts us with a major challenge: there are some seven million teachers in Latin America and the Caribbean, according to a recent report by the World Bank, representing 4 percent of the region's total labor force and 20 percent of its professional workers, and their combined salaries are equivalent to nearly 4 percent of regional GDP. They work in conditions ranging from open air classrooms in the countryside to plush air conditioned schools in rich urban neighborhoods.

How then, can we improve teacher performance across the region, with all of these local variations?

The World Bank, in their report "Great Teachers: How to Raise Student Learning in Latin America and the Caribbean," tackles this massive question. In perhaps the most comprehensive report on the teaching profession in Latin America, the researchers made more than 15,000 unannounced visits to classrooms in more than 3,000 public schools between 2009 and 2013.

They came to a number of interesting conclusions. As the Economist magazine summarizes the findings:

The main reason for Latin America's educational failure is simple. The region churns out large numbers of teachers recruited from less-bright school leavers. It trains them badly and pays them peanuts (between 10 percent and 50 percent less than other professionals). So they teach badly.

In fact, the World Bank found that Latin American teachers as a whole spend just 65 percent of their time actually teaching -- compared with the recommended international benchmark of around 85 percent. Nor is this a problem easily solved with new technologies or better materials -- the study points out that even in schools possessing internet connectivity, laptops, or other advanced teaching aids, teachers generally keep using what they know, the blackboard.

Thus the numbers about wasted time in the classroom point to the more fundamental problem: the way that teachers are recruited, trained, and compensated for performance. Unfortunately, making any changes in this area is no easy task, given the influential interest groups with a stake in the status quo -- including teachers unions, university administrations, and teacher training institutes.

However, not all improvements are necessarily complex, according to Javier Luque, one of the authors of the World Bank report and an education specialist at the Inter-American Development Bank. Luque explains:

"Students are at school to learn," Luque adds, "and thus all the actors in the system should align to ensure that learning takes place. This would seem to be a very simple recommendation, but unfortunately it is not happening." That may be because many of the underperforming teachers already possess the necessary technical knowledge or cognitive skills -- but the lack of clear signals related to student learning are holding them back.

At the same time, Luque argues that deeper reforms are also necessary. "These will relate to revamping teacher training and evaluation systems," he says. That is critically necessary "in order to get better information about what is working and what is not -- so we can figure out how and where to intervene."

Some countries, like Chile, Mexico, Peru, and Ecuador, have passed legislation to increase evaluations. Elsewhere, major cities like Rio de Janeiro and Buenos Aires are taking the lead. In each of these cases, improvements faced strong opposition from teachers unions, who are opposed to linking performance reviews with career advancement.

But in my conversation with Luque, he insists that those "signals" are exactly what our education systems are missing. "In Latin America, most classrooms are like a 'black box': the system doesn't really know what is going on internally. That substantially limits the chances of improvement." Making this explicit -- and tying it to a rigorous evaluation process -- could make a big difference.

The report put together by Luque and his colleagues presents not only a bracing picture of Latin American education but also a number of good ideas for fixing it: better principals, more peer-to-peer training, and reducing teachers' administrative workload.

Still, it focuses less on what will be needed on a system-wide level to achieve these classroom reforms. The political arena is where the real challenges are, and with powerful stakeholders ready to oppose any changes, reformers must build political strategies as well as policy recommendations. That, perhaps, is a good topic for the next study.

Education Quality in Latin America Comes Down to Teachers


It seems like almost every day more evidence comes in showing that teachers are the most important single factor when it comes to education quality. While that makes intuitive sense, it is also critical to have empirical evidence to support it.

Steinger, Iscoe & Greene Latin Heritage Law Student Scholarship


Are you a Hispanic law student, or seeking to attend a law school to receive your degree? Steinger, Iscoe & Greene are pleased to present a $1,000 scholarship to one student of Hispanic descent seeking to obtain a law degree.

White House representative speaks about Latino education


Davis said the initiative first emerged as an executive order in 1990 to find ways to increase opportunities in education, focusing on how to raise awareness about the challenges many Latinos face in higher education.

Crossing the bridge: how far would you go to find the right school for your child?

bigstock Little girls walking to school 56331140 resized 600

Watching my 10-year-old skip down the street, I blinked back tears. Sadie had spent the day visiting a small school — housed inside a cozy San Francisco Victorian — for kids with learning differences. I couldn’t remember the last time she left school happy.

The private sector is increasing its role in Brazilian education

bigstock Brazil Small Flag on a Map Bac 63333178 resized 600

In June of this year, Brazil’s Congress approved one of the most ambitious education reforms in the history of the country – the National Education Plan, or PNE. Among other things, the PNE mandates an increase in education expenditure to at least 10 percent of GDP, guarantees basic universal education for all, and will expand higher education access.

Emerging Economies Are Exporting Education


Universities in the United States have long been - and in many ways still are - the most attractive higher education option for students around the world. As recent research from the Brookings Institution demonstrates, the U.S. is a "global hub of higher education."

Black and Hispanic Students are Failing at an Alarming Rate in Some New York City Schools


Washington, DC – The Black Alliance for Educational Options (BAEO) is appalled and dismayed at the discovery that at least 90 public schools in New York City failed to pass a single Black or Hispanic student on the state standardized tests in 2013, according to a study, The Forgotten Fourth, released by Families for Excellent Schools.

Take conflict out of 'Parent Trigger' law


On a recent sunny afternoon, mothers gathered in an apartment complex near the Happiest Place on Earth – Disneyland. Parents eagerly discussed their plans to access the key – not to the magical kingdom with its promise of Tomorrowland – but to the American Dream itself. The key, for them, is transforming their neighborhood school, Palm Lane Elementary, which has languished on the California Department of Education’s chronically underperforming school list for 10 years.

A National Imperative: Helping English Learners

bigstock Health Care Cost 5755326 resized 600

For a long time, I have wanted to offer my perspective on the needs of the nearly six million English learners (ELs) in our public schools. My interest is both professional and personal – I was an English learner myself. My parents came from Puerto Rico in search of opportunity, and I was born in New York City, growing up with Spanish as my first language. 

All Posts